So you're in the market for a new screwdriver set. Not just any old set though. You want the best screwdriver set your money can buy. Let's start by evaluating what you currently have.

How many screwdrivers are in your junk drawer? Don't act so innocent -- we ALL have a junk drawer. If you're like me, there are probably no less than five random screwdrivers in that drawer. There are also several pairs of pliers, a razor knife, and 18 partially used picture hanging kits. There used to be a hammer too. It ran away from home after being left in the yard two years ago when the kids used it to squash bugs.

At least one of your screwdrivers has a broken handle. It was used as a hammer while hanging a picture last summer. It began its life as a Phillip's Head screwdriver, but now it is just a makeshift hammer. What else could you do with it after the head got stripped trying to unscrew something five years ago? You needed a hammer, and it begged to be used.

Ah... the memories. But now it's time to stop screwing around (haha - see what I did there?). It's time to buy a new screwdriver set that has matching handles. You don't have time to hunt around, and you can't afford a gold-plated set. You want something that works. Lucky for you, the best screwdriver set for your toolbox doesn't have to cost an arm and a leg.

best screwdriver set


PRODUCT

IMAGE

RATING

DETAILS

STANLEY 60-100 10-PIECE STANDARD FLUTED SCREWDRIVER SET

best screwdriver set-Stanley 60-100 10-Piece Standard Fluted Screwdriver Set

Craftsman 8 Piece Phillips and Slotted Set

best screwdriver set- Craftsman 8 Piece Phillips and Slotted Set

SnapOn 8 pc Instinct® Soft Grip Combination Screwdriver Set

best screwdriver set-Snap-On 8 Piece Green Handle Combination Screwdriver Set

Mac Tools 8-PC. COMFORT-GRIP™ Combination Screwdriver Set

best screwdriver set-MAC TOOLS 8 Piece Comfort-Grip Screwdriver Set

Pittsburgh 12-Piece Cushion Grip Screwdriver Set

best screwdriver set- Pittsburgh 12 Piece Cushion Grip Screwdriver Set

DWHT62058 Dewalt 8PC Screwdriver Set

best screwdriver set-DEWALT DWHT62054 MAX FIT 4 Piece Screwdriver Set

Husky 15 pc Black Handled Screwdriver Set

best screwdriver set-Screwdriver Set (15-Piece) by Husky

Milwaukee 48-22-2018 8-Piece Screwdriver Set

best screwdriver set-Milwaukee 48-22-2018 8-Piece Screwdriver Set

KING Screwdriver Se

best screwdriver set- KING Screwdriver Set

Performance Tool W1726 26-Pc Screwdriver Set 

best screwdriver set-Performance Tool W1726 26-Piece Screwdriver Set with Rack

Gear Wrench 12 Pc. Phillips®/Slotted Dual Material Screwdriver Set

best screwdriver set-GearWrench 80051 12 Piece Combination Dual Material Screwdriver Set

best screwdriver set

Stanley 60-100 10-Piece Standard Fluted Screwdriver Set


best screwdriver set-Stanley 60-100 10-Piece Standard Fluted Screwdriver Set

We selected this set because, at ten pieces, it will suit most home application uses. It includes the most standard sized drivers in both flathead and Phillips head, and Stubby handled drivers plus a bonus of two pocket drivers. The price on this set won't set your wallet on fire as it comes in under $20 whether you buy it online or in a brick and mortar store.

The tips are hardened, which helps with a non-slip grip. This is a huge aid when working with stripped screws. The shafts are constructed of heat treated, rust-resistant steel with nickel plating. The handles are designed to be ergonomic and slip-resistant. This set has a limited lifetime warranty.

Although 62 percent of reviewers on Amazon rated this set with five stars, the overall rating stands at 4.0 out of 5.0 stars. The negative comments express concerns over the fluted tip design on the Phillips head drivers, poor stability, and easy breakage. These are not heavy duty screwdrivers, but appear to stand up well for normal household jobs.

PROS

  • This screwdriver stand up well for normal household jobs
  • Tips are hardened, which helps with a non-slip grip
  •  Handles are designed to be ergonomic and slip-resistant

CONS

  • Fluted tip design on the Phillips head drivers, poor stability, and easy breakage
  • These are not heavy duty screwdrivers,

QUALITY

PRICE

RATING

$$

CRAFTSMAN 8 PIECE PHILLIPS AND SLOTTED SET, 9-47136


best screwdriver set- Craftsman 8 Piece Phillips and Slotted Set


While slightly more expensive than some sets, we selected this Craftsman 8-piece set for its versatility. It includes all the most common sized standard drivers. There are no Stubby drivers in this set, so if you're working in small spaces, you might have to purchase those separately.

Craftsman tools have long been known for their quality of construction and durability. They stand up to the tougher jobs around the house. They also have a lifetime warranty which includes complete replacement if they break under normal usage. This set is available at various retail stores and via Amazon. The price averages between $$ - $$ , depending on the point of purchase.

Eighty percent of the reviewers on Amazon gave this set a five-star rating. It holds an overall rating of 4.6 out of 5.0 stars. Most of the critical reviews seem to revolve around the fact that these were made in China and not in the US, and that the packaging was difficult to get into.

PROS

  • Craftsman tools have long been known for their quality of construction and durability
  • They stand up to the tougher jobs around the house.
  • They also have a lifetime warranty which includes complete replacement if they break under normal usage

CONS

  • These screwdriver were made in China and not in the US, and that the packaging was difficult to get into.

QUALITY

PRICE

RATING

$$

SNAPON 8 PC INSTINCT® SOFT GRIP COMBINATION SCREWDRIVER SET


best screwdriver set-Snap-On 8 Piece Green Handle Combination Screwdriver Set

Decidedly on the pricey side, SnapOn tools are designed for professional use. If you want quality and have the money, you cannot go wrong with this set. But if having just under $$$ worth of screwdrivers sitting around collecting dust between projects is an issue, stick to the less expensive brands and sets. This may be the best screwdriver set ever, but the price is enough to cause a divorce.

This set offers five flathead drivers and three Phillips head drivers in a handy storage tray that will slide into almost any drawer to keep your set organized and easy to find. This set can be purchased online through the SnapOn retail site, or on eBay through several sellers.

PROS

  •  If you want quality and have the money, you cannot go wrong with this set.
  • This set offers five flathead drivers and three Phillips head drivers in a handy storage tray that will slide into almost any drawer to keep your set organized and easy to find.

CONS

  • This screwdriver is a little bit pricey.

QUALITY

PRICE

RATING

$$$

MAC TOOLS 8-PC. COMFORT-GRIP™ COMBINATION SCREWDRIVER SET


best screwdriver set-MAC TOOLS 8 Piece Comfort-Grip Screwdriver Set

Mac Tools, like the SnapOn tools, are expensive. Designed for heavy duty mechanical work, they include features like acid-resistant handles, and these drivers will stand up to the most daunting tasks. The square design of the handles keeps them from rolling away from you when you set them down.

If money is a concern, skip on past this set too. It comes in at under $$$ from the Mac Tools online retail center. There are also several offers for sets via eBay. Even though there are few consumer reviews, as an owner and user of Mac Tools, I can tell you that the quality, durability, and dependability of these screwdrivers are among the best in the business. This is one of the best screwdriver sets on the market.

PROS

  • Designed for heavy duty mechanical work, they include features like acid-resistant handles
  • These drivers will stand up to the most daunting tasks.
  • The square design of the handles keeps them from rolling away from you when you set them down.

CONS

  • SnapOn tools, are expensive.

QUALITY

PRICE

RATING

$$$ 

PITTSBURGH 12-PIECE CUSHION GRIP SCREWDRIVER SET


best screwdriver set- Pittsburgh 12 Piece Cushion Grip Screwdriver Set

To represent the Pittsburgh line of tools available through Harbor Freight, Amazon, and other retailers, we selected the Pittsburgh 12 Piece Cushion Grip Screwdriver Set. The cushion-gripped raised rubber handles make them comfortable to use. The shafts are constructed from chrome vanadium steel, and the magnetic tips make it easy to keep your loose screws from getting lost.

There are only three reviews posted on Amazon, which isn't very helpful, but the overall rating is at 4.1 out of 5.0 stars. Ninety percent of the customers who shopped with Harbor Freight would recommend this screwdriver set. It is rated at 4.3 out of 5.0 stars on the Harbor Freight review site. At under $, the price can't be beaten for a standard set to complete your Honey-Do list.

PROS

  • The cushion-gripped raised rubber handles make them comfortable to use.
  • The shafts are constructed from chrome vanadium steel, and the magnetic tips make it easy to keep your loose screws from getting lost.

CONS

  • Cheaply made but useful. Not bad.

QUALITY

PRICE

RATING

$$

DWHT62058 DEWALT 8PC SCREWDRIVER SET


best screwdriver set-DEWALT DWHT62054 MAX FIT 4 Piece Screwdriver Set

The handles on these drivers include an ergonomic quad-lobe design for more comfort. The handle also promotes a better grip strength to produce more torque. The Max Fit tip design claims to eliminate stripped screws. The shafts are made of tool grade S2 steel bar, and the tips are CNC machined for consistency. price is $$. is in the affordable range for most shoppers.

Most people buy this set at brick and mortar stores, so Amazon is only sporting eight reviews. Capturing 3.9 out of 5.0 stars, this set doesn't exactly speak well for the Dewalt line of tools. But you can check them out at Home Depot, Lowe's, Walmart, and many other retail stores.

PROS

  • The handles on these drivers include an ergonomic quad-lobe design for more comfort.
  • The handle also promotes a better grip strength to produce more torque.

CONS

  • This set doesn't exactly speak well for the Dewalt line of tools.

QUALITY

PRICE

RATING

$$

HUSKY 15 PC BLACK HANDLED SCREWDRIVER SET


best screwdriver set-Screwdriver Set (15-Piece) by Husky

This set has a few more drivers with different lengths. At a price of under $$, it is available both online through Amazon and at established retail locations. This set contains eight flathead drivers and six Phillips head drivers in a variety of sizes. It will provide versatility and functionality.

There aren't many reviews available on this specific set, but Husky tools, in general, hold up fairly well for routine maintenance tasks around the house. They have other sets designed for more industrial use, which are sturdier.

PROS

  •  It will provide versatility and functionality.
  • Husky tools, in general, hold up fairly well for routine maintenance tasks around the house.
  • They have other sets designed for more industrial use, which are sturdier.

CONS

  • This set has a few more drivers with different lengths.

QUALITY

PRICE

RATING

$$

MILWAUKEE 48-22-2018 8-PIECE SCREWDRIVER SET


best screwdriver set-Milwaukee 48-22-2018 8-Piece Screwdriver Set

This durable set is available through Amazon, various retail stores, and (don't laugh) Acme Tools (It was good enough for Wile E. Coyote). It is priced is $$ depending on where you buy it.

On Amazon, it rates 4.4 out of 5.0 stars with 75 percent of reviewers giving it a five-star rating. Milwaukee tools are dependable, sturdy, and deliver a lifetime of use.

PROS

  • This durable set is available through Amazon, various retail stores
  • Milwaukee tools are dependable, sturdy, and deliver a lifetime of use.

CONS

  • Would rather not have the electric and Alan head drivers included in set, but overall quality is good.

QUALITY

PRICE

RATING

$$

KING SCREWDRIVER SET W/STAND (26 PCS)


best screwdriver set- KING Screwdriver Set

KING offers a 26 pc boxed set of screwdrivers for under $$ through Home DepotAmazon, and other retailers. The handy boxed set can be stored on a countertop or hung on a pegboard for easy access.

Each driver has non-slip cushioned grips and magnetic tips. The shafts are made from chrome vanadium steel. The set has a one-year warranty. It has only received four reviews on the Home Depot site, but they were all five-star ratings.

PROS

  • The handy boxed set can be stored on a countertop or hung on a pegboard for easy access.
  • Each driver has non-slip cushioned grips and magnetic tips.

CONS

  • Works fine stand is cheap but I would take that over crappy tools.

QUALITY

PRICE

RATING

$$

PERFORMANCE TOOL W1726 26-PC SCREWDRIVER SET W/ RACK


best screwdriver set-Performance Tool W1726 26-Piece Screwdriver Set with Rack

Performance Tool offers a 26 pc set very similar to the KING set, right down to the stand. The shafts are constructed of satin finish chrome vanadium steel, with magnetic tips and non-slip grips. The biggest outward difference is in pricing. The Performance Tool screwdriver set is available on Amazon and priced is $$. There is no warranty information available without emailing the manufacturer to request it.

Amazon reviewers give it 4.3 out of 5.0 stars. The biggest complaint from negative reviewers seems to be in the quality and durability area. While these appear to be fine for normal household tasks, they don't stand up to rugged use. What people liked was the selection of various sizes to complete different tasks.

PROS

  • The shafts are constructed of satin finish chrome vanadium steel, with magnetic tips and non-slip grips.
  • While these appear to be fine for normal household tasks, 

CONS

  • The biggest complaint from negative reviewers seems to be in the quality and durability area.
  • They don't stand up to rugged use.

QUALITY

PRICE

RATING

$$

GEAR WRENCH 12 PC. PHILLIPS®/SLOTTED DUAL MATERIAL SCREWDRIVER SET


best screwdriver set-GearWrench 80051 12 Piece Combination Dual Material Screwdriver Set

This set boasts a dual material handle designed for comfort and performance, in addition to being oil and solvent resistant. The tri-lobe handle design offers a better grip. Each driver has a black oxide non-slip tip and is laser etched with the part number and size. Gear Wrench displays their entire line on their website but refers you to outside distributors if you want to make a purchase.

Gear Wrench products are available on Amazon and at retail stores like Home Depot and Sears. They range in price is $$ depending on where you shop.

With only one review posted at the Home Depot site, it carries 4.0 out of 5.0 stars. Don't let that discourage from selecting this set though. I have worked with many Gear Wrench products and have been very satisfied with the overall quality, workmanship, and durability. If the company applied the same quality to these as to their wrenches, the money would be well-spent.

PROS

  • This set boasts a dual material handle designed for comfort and performance, in addition to being oil and solvent resistant.
  • The tri-lobe handle design offers a better grip.
  • Gear Wrench products overall quality, workmanship, and durability. 

CONS

  • Not as good as I hope

QUALITY

PRICE

RATING

$$

Screwdrivers are a Serious Tool


We use screwdrivers for so many tasks. They remove the air cleaner on the lawnmower so we can spray starter fluid into the carburetor. They open the spackling paste tub when we finally patch that hole in the dining room wall. Teeny tiny ones remove the safety covers on the battery compartment for junior's favorite toy.

Which came first, the screwdriver or the screw? Screws, of course. They've been around forever, or at least since the first century. The first screws were wooden and used in wine presses to squish grapes. Let there be wine! Oh, wait, we have to keep going here.

Metal screws weren't introduced until 15 centuries later around 1770. Since the creation of screws, the need for a tool to easily manipulate them was born. Enter the slotted screwdriver, which held the world's attention for 130 years.

SLOTTED SCREWDRIVERS

Screwdrivers began their humble existence as a tool called a "turn-screw." These were used as an attachment in the brace-and-bit toolkit of carpenters. The actual flat head screwdriver made its first appearance after 1800. Flathead screwdrivers ruled the world until the early 1930s when the Phillips head screw and driver were invented.

The various sizes start with itty-bitty, teeny tiny, and you need a magnifying glass to see them. Those are used on the itty-bitty, teeny tiny screws that hold your eyeglasses together. The largest non-specialty slotted screwdriver is a half inch wide and works with size 18 - 24 screws.

The size of a flathead screwdriver is determined by the actual width of the tip, not the length of the shaft. Sizing is measured in graduating increments in fractions of inches. When stated, the width of the head (the working end) is stated, followed by the length of the shaft (distance from the tip to the base of the handle). A 3/32" by 1 1/2" screwdriver would have a working blade 3/32" wide and a shaft that is 1 1/2" long. That particular screwdriver also answers to the name "Stubby."

The best screwdriver set will consist of various sized heads and shafts to allow versatility in job performance. A Stubby is great for inside a cabinet and in some tight spaces. But it won't reach that screw at the base of your car's battery hold down clamp.

PHILLIPS HEAD SCREWDRIVERS

Henry Phillips invented Phillips head screws in the 1930s. Originally used in automated assembly lines for the steadily increasing automobile manufacturing industry.

Because of the need for screws that could take greater torque and hold things together tighter, we now have cross-headed screwdrivers. Poof. American ingenuity.

Unlike the slotted screwdrivers, which come in many sizes, Phillips head screwdrivers on have four basic sizes. Sizes #1 and #2 are the most common sizes and will handle the bulk of your indoor handyman tasks. The big boys, #3 and #4, will have an honored, if seldom-used, place in most sets. There is also a smaller size, #0, which Is the size you need for all the access panels on kid's toys. Phillips head screwdrivers also come in a variety of shaft lengths. Yes, there is a little Stubby in this family too.

HOW WE REVIEWED


Our review consisted of my personal experience and reviews supplied by other consumers. We checked statistics, quality, ease of use, the reliability of brand, price, and the number of pieces available in each set. It would have been easier to write them on slips of paper and draw one out of a bucket. But you deserve more, and we hope that we have provided that for you.

There is no greater compliment than word-of-mouth from one user to another when it comes to tool recommendations. We all want the greatest value for our dollar, which is why you're here and not down at the hardware store with your wallet out.

REVIEWS -- THE BEST OF THE BEST SCREWDRIVER SET


As a former forklift and heavy equipment mechanic, I tend to favor the SnapOn, Mac, and Craftsman brands. But as a general duty handy ma'am performing routine maintenance around the house, my wallet has other ideas. The best screwdriver set will range in price from an affordable $$ to well over $$$ for a comparable number of drivers.

Fit and feel are important to me. Because this is a hand tool, the size of your hand will play a part in your final selection. As a person with smaller hands, a larger handled tool tends to decrease the sureness of my grip. Someone with larger hands would have the opposite problem.

OUR CHOICE OF THE BEST SCREWDRIVER SET


The best screwdriver set in our line up is the SnapOn 8 pc Instinct®, but we did not select it because of the price. The same with the Mac Tools set. While both are exemplary sets, unless you are using them all day, every day, they are cost prohibitive.

Based on customer reviews, pricing, and a long track record of satisfied users, we selected the Craftsman 8 Piece Phillips and Slotted Set, 9-47136 as the best screwdriver set. With the lifetime warranty, you cannot go wrong. The price is comparable to similar sets. The versatility offered by the different sized drivers will assist you in completing all your tasks around the house and garage.

HAPPY SHOPPING!


Get busy and clean out that junk drawer while you're waiting on that package to arrive. You're about to be the proud owner of the best screwdriver set in the universe. You need a place to keep it. Unless you have kids. If you have kids, you need a locked safe on the top shelf in the back of your closet. Because if your kids get to it, there will be two broken screwdrivers left in your brand new set by this weekend.

We hope you enjoyed our review of the best screwdriver sets. The research that went into this made me woefully aware of the inadequacies of my own screwdriver collection. Sigh...

 

Featured image: CC By-ND 2.0 by Barbara Olsen via Flickr